Bambu Lab P1 / X1 / X1C / X1CC Filament Spool Switcher & Winder if you use AMS

Purely mechanically controlled filament winder for Bambu Lab P1, X1, X1C or X1CC 3D Printer. (but Prusa or others also)
15,543
85 k
739
488 k
updated March 2, 2023

Comments

Sehr schlechtes Modell ... Viele Teile passen gar nicht!
Beispiel die Lager muss mit mit sehr viel Kraftauswand, sowie mit einem Hammer montieren. (Filament ist gebrochen)
Löcher für Schrauben zu groß sodass sie nicht halten, Sekundenkleber ist eine Hilfe.
Teilweise auch zu klein.
Die Dateien wurden mit 6 Kant gedruckt, im Video dennoch wurde es so vorgeführt
das es runde aufnahmen mit Nasen sind.
Ergebnis nochmal einen großteil Drucken.
Ich bereue diesen Druck gestartet zu haben, habe ihn nun aufgegeben. (edited)

@Dennis_1704156 I think its pretty unfair of you to 1-star the hard work of this creator, providing this exceptional model for free. Its quite obvious from all the successful prints that the problem here is the calibration of YOUR own printer. Do you really think the model is bad if there are hundreds and hundreds of succesful prints? I really hope common sense preveils and you revise or delete your unfair review.

@Dennis_1704156 I would agree that your 1 star for your own issues is sadly mistaken, I have printed this on two different printers with great success, Ender 3 and a Voron v2.4 Calibrate your own printer then start printing models, not everything will work OOB its up to you to know how to skew things. Good luck to you

@Ross_K_1600475 it is obvious to everyone with a hint in engineering that this model was designed awfully and if it assembles without problem by someone than that's someone's printer in dire need of calibration.

@_577321 honestly, I have no idea what you're trying to say with your comment. What is "obvious to everyone" is that the vast majority of people, including myself, have printed this without issue. 657 reviews averaging 4.5 stars. So clearly the problem is not the model, but the person or printer. I'm looking in your profile and I do not see you creating any models whatsoever, so you're in no position to criticise this creators efforts. (edited)

@Ross_K_1600475 If you'd have the ability to read, you'd know that "vast majority of people... 657 reviews averaging 4.5 stars." and "everyone with a hint in engineering" are different groups of people. I only had to open the model and look at the 22mm bore for the 22mm bearing to know that the author knows nothing about tolerances/fits and design for manufacturing. You apparently don't see a problem with people praising the author who don't publish their models here. But those can't criticize, right?

@_577321 I think you've lost the plot. I'm not talking about engineering excellence and neither was the original post. The OP is saying the model simply doesn't work. Given how almost everyone that has printed it (including me) had no issues at all, its clear the printer is out of calibration and not a fault of the model. Could the model have bigger tolerences for out of calibraiton printers? Sure - but that's not what the OP is criticising. You need to relax before you have an aneurysm. And yes, I think there's a big difference between someone praising vs someone who has contributed nothing to the community, except moan about a problem that is down to their own printer on a FREE model.

@Ross_K_1600475 And you again failed to realize that it is definitely a problem with model and not printer. And everyone that have no problem with model have problem with their printers. Cuz the way it is designed it could only work out in metalworking when you heating the hole part (for material expansion) and cooling the shaft part (for material contraction) to press fit it in permanent manner. Which is obviously not the case with printed parts since even PLA have some shrinkage after heating down so the hole became smaller than bearing it 'designed' to fit in and there's no possible way to calibrate printer for that as shrinkage depends on parts dimensions. You can't praise someone for waste of time and filament no matter if it is free or not.

@_577321 I'm sorry but the evidence of thousands of successful makes and very few "failure" comments suggests there's no issue with the model. Your "feelings" and your "hint of engineering" experience mean nothing when compared with the evidence on Printables. Its a simple as that. If you were not able to get it to print but thousands of others were, its quite clear where the problem is. And probably explains why you're being so defensive.

Show all comments