{"data":{"model":{"id":"292426","slug":"sad-face-a-disscussion-on-3d-models","name":"SAD FACE A DISSCUSSION ON 3D MODELS","authorship":null,"club":false,"excludeCommercialUsage":false,"price":null,"eduProject":null,"ratingAvg":"0E-10","myRating":null,"ratingCount":0,"description":"

Original discussion found here.

An inspection on copyright law

https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:1350837/comments

While years may have passed 3d models and their copyright still have no solid guides for copyright.

Whether the 3d model can be classed as art or simply an interpretation of software and under the copyright of that software creator.

While sites such as printables.com and others state files can be creative commons and similar US and EU law remains unclear.

Simply by importing a file into slicing software US and EU law states that the art can be seen as derivatives and not the original art, previous cases infer that creative commons no-derivatives licenses are fundamentally incompatible with 3d printing.

Also does an artist who creates a Mickley mouse design own copyright of that model or does Dismey (names changed) own the overall rights to the piece.

While I find the argument of \u201cyou put something in a public space\u201d entirely simplistic and moronic there is some real problems where the law stands.

","category":{"id":"14","path":[{"id":"13","name":"Art & Design","nameEn":"Art & Design","description":"Explore 3D printed works of art and breathtaking designs. Download premium STL files of movie characters, design accessories, miniatures, busts, and animals.","__typename":"CategoryType"},{"id":"14","name":"Sculptures","nameEn":"Sculptures","description":"It's not sci-fi to have all your avatars printed in 3D. Busts of famous people, movie heroes statues, animal creatures, or miniatures. Print them all!","__typename":"CategoryType"}],"__typename":"CategoryType"},"modified":"2022-10-10T10:48:40.580105+00:00","firstPublish":"2022-10-10T10:48:40.564090+00:00","datePublished":"2022-10-10T10:48:40.566475+00:00","dateCreatedThingiverse":null,"nsfw":false,"summary":"Original discussion found here.\n\nAn inspection on copyright law\n\nhttps://www.thingiverse.com/thing:1350837/comments","likesCount":3,"makesCount":0,"liked":null,"printDuration":null,"numPieces":0,"weight":null,"nozzleDiameters":null,"usedMaterial":null,"layerHeights":null,"mmu":false,"materials":[],"dateFeatured":null,"downloadCount":9,"displayCount":244,"filesCount":1,"privateCollectionsCount":1,"publicCollectionsCount":0,"pdfFilePath":"media/prints/292426/pdfs/292426-sad-face-a-disscussion-on-3d-models-a40242e6-4f41-4ffb-b9b4-a040442433f5.pdf","commentCount":3,"userGcodeCount":0,"remixCount":0,"canBeRated":false,"printer":null,"image":{"id":"1258285","filePath":"media/prints/292426/images/2569819_879b591e-3a16-45ca-a4b7-966ed8919c1b/960x0.jpg","rotation":0,"imageHash":"UxgGFYItRqeThndtqQl4jVtwmQW4","imageWidth":960,"imageHeight":720,"__typename":"PrintImageType"},"images":[{"id":"1258285","filePath":"media/prints/292426/images/2569819_879b591e-3a16-45ca-a4b7-966ed8919c1b/960x0.jpg","rotation":0,"imageHash":"UxgGFYItRqeThndtqQl4jVtwmQW4","imageWidth":960,"imageHeight":720,"__typename":"PrintImageType"}],"tags":[],"thingiverseLink":null,"filesType":null,"previewFile":{"id":"1316386","filePreviewPath":"media/prints/292426/stls/2569808_c840cb91-052d-40c1-928c-cabab738dd27/sad_face_preview.png","__typename":"STLType"},"license":{"id":"7","disallowRemixing":false,"__typename":"LicenseType"},"remixParents":[],"remixDescription":null,"__typename":"PrintType","user":{"id":"284308","handle":"Ninja3dPrinting","verified":false,"dateVerified":null,"publicUsername":"Ninja3dPrinting","avatarFilePath":"media/auth/2a9d41f6-5c76-44d7-83c9-a177bacae505.jpg","badgesProfileLevel":{"profileLevel":15,"__typename":"BadgesProfileLevelType"},"__typename":"UserType","isFollowedByMe":false,"isHiddenForMe":false,"canBeFollowed":true,"billingAccountType":"personal","lowestTierPrice":null,"highlightedModels":{"models":[{"id":"289850","name":"Oni Cyber Punk Mask by 3DPrintGeneral original post SeanAranda","slug":"oni-cyber-punk-mask-by-3dprintgeneral-original-pos","ratingAvg":"4.8965517241","likesCount":718,"liked":null,"datePublished":"2024-10-21T09:17:31.638245+00:00","dateFeatured":null,"firstPublish":"2022-10-06T10:58:51.937423+00:00","downloadCount":2379,"mmu":false,"category":{"id":"78","path":[{"id":"76","name":"Costumes & Accessories","nameEn":"Costumes & Accessories","__typename":"CategoryType"},{"id":"78","name":"Masks","nameEn":"Masks","__typename":"CategoryType"}],"__typename":"CategoryType"},"modified":"2024-10-21T09:17:32.144570+00:00","image":{"id":"1249148","filePath":"media/prints/289850/images/2551493_298ddc86-2597-4150-b9bd-92a71650e326/mask-2.jpg","rotation":0,"imageHash":"YxgSDwL6aHh5h4h5iGeIh4eHafgXCI8A","imageWidth":2208,"imageHeight":2208,"__typename":"PrintImageType"},"nsfw":false,"club":false,"price":null,"user":{"id":"284308","handle":"Ninja3dPrinting","verified":false,"dateVerified":null,"publicUsername":"Ninja3dPrinting","avatarFilePath":"media/auth/2a9d41f6-5c76-44d7-83c9-a177bacae505.jpg","badgesProfileLevel":{"profileLevel":15,"__typename":"BadgesProfileLevelType"},"__typename":"UserType","isHiddenForMe":false},"latestContestResult":null,"__typename":"PrintType"},{"id":"435893","name":"Destiny 2 Sun shot","slug":"destiny-2-sun-shot","ratingAvg":"5.0000000000","likesCount":188,"liked":null,"datePublished":"2023-03-28T14:29:48.950511+00:00","dateFeatured":null,"firstPublish":"2023-03-28T14:29:48.948509+00:00","downloadCount":488,"mmu":false,"category":{"id":"77","path":[{"id":"76","name":"Costumes & Accessories","nameEn":"Costumes & Accessories","__typename":"CategoryType"},{"id":"77","name":"Cosplay & Costumes in general","nameEn":"Cosplay & Costumes in general","__typename":"CategoryType"}],"__typename":"CategoryType"},"modified":"2023-03-28T14:29:48.963100+00:00","image":{"id":"1725483","filePath":"media/prints/435893/images/3606322_dad6ba46-66cd-4084-8025-2d8bdb06c15c/33199f44ba9a124c8bfec703ef303ec0.jpg","rotation":0,"imageHash":"oegJFYJqenl1eXhvead4jpJvyiBe","imageWidth":628,"imageHeight":472,"__typename":"PrintImageType"},"nsfw":false,"club":false,"price":null,"user":{"id":"284308","handle":"Ninja3dPrinting","verified":false,"dateVerified":null,"publicUsername":"Ninja3dPrinting","avatarFilePath":"media/auth/2a9d41f6-5c76-44d7-83c9-a177bacae505.jpg","badgesProfileLevel":{"profileLevel":15,"__typename":"BadgesProfileLevelType"},"__typename":"UserType","isHiddenForMe":false},"latestContestResult":null,"__typename":"PrintType"},{"id":"444336","name":"Hextraction Set","slug":"hextraction-set","ratingAvg":"4.7692307692","likesCount":187,"liked":null,"datePublished":"2023-04-06T13:24:09.988430+00:00","dateFeatured":null,"firstPublish":"2023-04-06T13:21:55.633774+00:00","downloadCount":1069,"mmu":false,"category":{"id":"33","path":[{"id":"30","name":"Toys & Games","nameEn":"Toys & Games","__typename":"CategoryType"},{"id":"33","name":"Puzzles & Brain-teasers","nameEn":"Puzzles & Brain-teasers","__typename":"CategoryType"}],"__typename":"CategoryType"},"modified":"2023-04-06T13:24:10.007212+00:00","image":{"id":"1755123","filePath":"media/prints/444336/images/3668455_1656beed-f2c0-481b-bc73-a1180e53b861/hextraction.png","rotation":0,"imageHash":"ahgGFYL4BYWNg1aHgqmXewiVoqEF","imageWidth":898,"imageHeight":658,"__typename":"PrintImageType"},"nsfw":false,"club":false,"price":null,"user":{"id":"284308","handle":"Ninja3dPrinting","verified":false,"dateVerified":null,"publicUsername":"Ninja3dPrinting","avatarFilePath":"media/auth/2a9d41f6-5c76-44d7-83c9-a177bacae505.jpg","badgesProfileLevel":{"profileLevel":15,"__typename":"BadgesProfileLevelType"},"__typename":"UserType","isHiddenForMe":false},"latestContestResult":null,"__typename":"PrintType"},{"id":"435900","name":"Destiny 2 Seals","slug":"destiny-2-seals","ratingAvg":"5.0000000000","likesCount":85,"liked":null,"datePublished":"2023-03-28T14:41:55.998173+00:00","dateFeatured":null,"firstPublish":"2023-03-28T14:41:55.996552+00:00","downloadCount":390,"mmu":false,"category":{"id":"41","path":[{"id":"13","name":"Art & Design","nameEn":"Art & Design","__typename":"CategoryType"},{"id":"41","name":"Other Art & Designs","nameEn":"Other Art & Designs","__typename":"CategoryType"}],"__typename":"CategoryType"},"modified":"2023-03-28T14:41:56.008780+00:00","image":{"id":"1725557","filePath":"media/prints/435900/images/3606371_7c9b89ca-4e94-40d3-a765-85d515e4023e/featured_preview_raid.png","rotation":0,"imageHash":"aAgGDYDulLaEeXdvdqd3azB5ApMX","imageWidth":628,"imageHeight":472,"__typename":"PrintImageType"},"nsfw":false,"club":false,"price":null,"user":{"id":"284308","handle":"Ninja3dPrinting","verified":false,"dateVerified":null,"publicUsername":"Ninja3dPrinting","avatarFilePath":"media/auth/2a9d41f6-5c76-44d7-83c9-a177bacae505.jpg","badgesProfileLevel":{"profileLevel":15,"__typename":"BadgesProfileLevelType"},"__typename":"UserType","isHiddenForMe":false},"latestContestResult":null,"__typename":"PrintType"},{"id":"435890","name":"OddWorks Destiny 2 Rat King","slug":"oddworks-destiny-2-rat-king","ratingAvg":"5.0000000000","likesCount":84,"liked":null,"datePublished":"2023-03-28T14:27:44.179548+00:00","dateFeatured":null,"firstPublish":"2023-03-28T14:27:44.177941+00:00","downloadCount":248,"mmu":false,"category":{"id":"77","path":[{"id":"76","name":"Costumes & Accessories","nameEn":"Costumes & Accessories","__typename":"CategoryType"},{"id":"77","name":"Cosplay & Costumes in general","nameEn":"Cosplay & Costumes in general","__typename":"CategoryType"}],"__typename":"CategoryType"},"modified":"2023-03-28T14:27:44.190196+00:00","image":{"id":"1725446","filePath":"media/prints/435890/images/3606316_5670e01d-17b3-4359-b28f-85bcee4aa146/d2008ff80a5e7c3848dd5e0b575cd637.jpeg","rotation":0,"imageHash":"U+gJFYJriHiPZXiZWZh5iPWM9pWd","imageWidth":628,"imageHeight":472,"__typename":"PrintImageType"},"nsfw":false,"club":false,"price":null,"user":{"id":"284308","handle":"Ninja3dPrinting","verified":false,"dateVerified":null,"publicUsername":"Ninja3dPrinting","avatarFilePath":"media/auth/2a9d41f6-5c76-44d7-83c9-a177bacae505.jpg","badgesProfileLevel":{"profileLevel":15,"__typename":"BadgesProfileLevelType"},"__typename":"UserType","isHiddenForMe":false},"latestContestResult":null,"__typename":"PrintType"},{"id":"435880","name":"OddWorks Destiny 2 Nezarec's Sin","slug":"oddworks-destiny-2-nezarecs-sin","ratingAvg":"0E-10","likesCount":60,"liked":null,"datePublished":"2023-03-28T14:20:12.291665+00:00","dateFeatured":null,"firstPublish":"2023-03-28T14:20:12.290013+00:00","downloadCount":99,"mmu":false,"category":{"id":"77","path":[{"id":"76","name":"Costumes & Accessories","nameEn":"Costumes & Accessories","__typename":"CategoryType"},{"id":"77","name":"Cosplay & Costumes in general","nameEn":"Cosplay & Costumes in general","__typename":"CategoryType"}],"__typename":"CategoryType"},"modified":"2023-03-28T14:20:12.302229+00:00","image":{"id":"1725388","filePath":"media/prints/435880/images/3606258_2e61156f-caa2-461b-adca-08b06bb11ce8/a136e88ccbbc8f2064b644434f9efce8.jpg","rotation":0,"imageHash":"afgZFYD4p1iJd4eIeId4iQaCNvo7","imageWidth":628,"imageHeight":472,"__typename":"PrintImageType"},"nsfw":false,"club":false,"price":null,"user":{"id":"284308","handle":"Ninja3dPrinting","verified":false,"dateVerified":null,"publicUsername":"Ninja3dPrinting","avatarFilePath":"media/auth/2a9d41f6-5c76-44d7-83c9-a177bacae505.jpg","badgesProfileLevel":{"profileLevel":15,"__typename":"BadgesProfileLevelType"},"__typename":"UserType","isHiddenForMe":false},"latestContestResult":null,"__typename":"PrintType"},{"id":"435897","name":"destiny 2 Quick Fang","slug":"destiny-2-quick-fang","ratingAvg":"5.0000000000","likesCount":49,"liked":null,"datePublished":"2023-03-28T14:31:14.809303+00:00","dateFeatured":null,"firstPublish":"2023-03-28T14:31:14.807675+00:00","downloadCount":134,"mmu":false,"category":{"id":"77","path":[{"id":"76","name":"Costumes & Accessories","nameEn":"Costumes & Accessories","__typename":"CategoryType"},{"id":"77","name":"Cosplay & Costumes in general","nameEn":"Cosplay & Costumes in general","__typename":"CategoryType"}],"__typename":"CategoryType"},"modified":"2023-03-28T14:31:14.819829+00:00","image":{"id":"1725498","filePath":"media/prints/435897/images/3606339_4d682339-409e-41b4-b7b2-3195f7195c6e/c9ab5ae9e0636266c3d9b97444de609b.jpg","rotation":0,"imageHash":"5fcRBYJ5eHhxeHh+eNh3jxDMCMGc","imageWidth":628,"imageHeight":472,"__typename":"PrintImageType"},"nsfw":false,"club":false,"price":null,"user":{"id":"284308","handle":"Ninja3dPrinting","verified":false,"dateVerified":null,"publicUsername":"Ninja3dPrinting","avatarFilePath":"media/auth/2a9d41f6-5c76-44d7-83c9-a177bacae505.jpg","badgesProfileLevel":{"profileLevel":15,"__typename":"BadgesProfileLevelType"},"__typename":"UserType","isHiddenForMe":false},"latestContestResult":null,"__typename":"PrintType"},{"id":"514301","name":"BullDog Speaker Housing","slug":"bulldog-speaker-housing","ratingAvg":"5.0000000000","likesCount":28,"liked":null,"datePublished":"2023-06-27T10:22:09.615732+00:00","dateFeatured":null,"firstPublish":"2023-06-27T10:22:09.613627+00:00","downloadCount":127,"mmu":false,"category":{"id":"25","path":[{"id":"21","name":"Gadgets","nameEn":"Gadgets","__typename":"CategoryType"},{"id":"25","name":"Audio","nameEn":"Audio","__typename":"CategoryType"}],"__typename":"CategoryType"},"modified":"2023-06-27T10:22:09.631012+00:00","image":{"id":"1985274","filePath":"media/prints/514301/images/4166392_09ba47cf-ac8f-4ae6-ac93-5ccf478bb816/aerobull-gold.jpg","rotation":0,"imageHash":"TRgKHAKLpnYIZoaWZ3gJdZNAJw==","imageWidth":1440,"imageHeight":2560,"__typename":"PrintImageType"},"nsfw":false,"club":false,"price":null,"user":{"id":"284308","handle":"Ninja3dPrinting","verified":false,"dateVerified":null,"publicUsername":"Ninja3dPrinting","avatarFilePath":"media/auth/2a9d41f6-5c76-44d7-83c9-a177bacae505.jpg","badgesProfileLevel":{"profileLevel":15,"__typename":"BadgesProfileLevelType"},"__typename":"UserType","isHiddenForMe":false},"latestContestResult":null,"__typename":"PrintType"}],"featured":false,"__typename":"HighlightedModelsType"},"designer":false,"stripeAccountActive":null,"membership":null},"contests":[],"contestsResults":[],"prusameterPoints":null,"latestContestResult":null}}}

SAD FACE A DISSCUSSION ON 3D MODELS

Comments